"Was $199, now $99": the discount that might not exist
The crossed-out price is doing most of the selling. Federal guidance has called inflated reference prices deceptive since 1967, but your best defense is checking the price history yourself.
WrongIt says 50% off, so it's a great deal.
RightIt's a deal only if the 'was' price was a real, recent price, and the 'now' price beats what other sellers charge.
What people get wrong#
Shoppers read the size of the discount as the size of the deal. A tag that says Was $199, now $99 feels like saving $100. But the $199 is a claim, not a fact, and the only number you actually pay is $99. If the item was never really sold at $199, or sat there for only a few days before the "sale," you saved nothing. You paid the regular price with extra theater.
With Black Friday falling on November 27 this year, the day after Thanksgiving, strike-through prices are about to be everywhere. This is the week to learn to read them.
What the rules say#
The Federal Trade Commission's Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, codified at 16 CFR Part 233 and dating to 1967, address this exact move. The first guide, on former price comparisons, says a reduction from a seller's own former price is legitimate if that price was "the actual, bona fide price at which the article was offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time."
It is just as clear about the opposite. If the former price is "fictitious," for example "an artificial, inflated price was established for the purpose of enabling the subsequent offer of a large reduction," then the bargain is false, and the "reduced" price "is, in reality, probably just the seller's regular price." The guide's own example: a retailer who normally sells a pen for $7.50 raises it to $10 for a few days, then advertises "Were $10, Now Only $7.50!" The guide calls that "obviously a false claim."
Two related guides cover the other common reference prices:
- "Compare at" or "retail value" claims should reflect prices at which substantial sales are actually being made in the area, not a few unrepresentative outlets charging more (16 CFR 233.2).
- "List price" or "MSRP" comparisons can mislead because, as the guide notes, "only in the rare case are all sales of an article at the manufacturer's suggested retail or list price" (16 CFR 233.3).
These are guides describing how the FTC views pricing claims, not a guarantee that every tag you see is compliant. Enforcement is case by case, and plenty of reference prices are never checked by anyone but you.
Why it works on us#
The crossed-out number is an anchor. Once you have seen $199, $99 feels cheap, regardless of what the item is worth or what other stores charge. A big percentage in red does the rest. The trick works even on people who know about it, which is why the fix is a habit rather than willpower.
The fix#
Headphones: was $199, now $99. Half off, buy now.
Headphones: $99 now; $89 to $110 at other sellers; tracked near $99 most of the year. Fair price, not a steal.
The comparison that matters is other real prices, not the seller's reference price.
Before you buy anything big this season:
- Write down the model number and compare that exact model, color and size across sellers. The FTC's online shopping advice recommends recording these details and learning "the total cost of the product, including shipping, handling, delivery, taxes, or other fees."
- Check the price history. The same FTC page notes that some comparison sites offer price alerts. A price-history chart shows at a glance whether the "was" price was ever the normal price or just a brief spike.
- Be skeptical of comparison sites, too. The FTC warns that some are run by manufacturers or rank only sellers that pay.
- Ask about price drops. Check whether the store price-matches or refunds the difference if the price falls soon after you buy, and whether sale or clearance items have stricter return rules.
Sources
Every factual claim on this page links to one of these. Checked November 18, 2026. See how we source.