Fewer vs. less: what the supermarket sign gets wrong
The basic rule takes one sentence. The exceptions are where careful writers get caught out, sometimes by being too strict.
WrongThere were less people at the meeting than last week.
RightThere were fewer people at the meeting than last week.
What people get wrong#
The traditional rule fits on an index card: fewer for things you can count, less for things you measure. The American Heritage Dictionary gives the textbook pair: fewer than four players, but less paper and less than a gallon of paint.
The common slip is using less with a plural count noun: less people, less mistakes, less calories. The Oxford Learner's Dictionary calls this "a very common error" and says it "is not considered correct in standard English." AHD's Usage Panel agrees. In its 2006 survey only 5 percent accepted There are less crowds at the mall these days.
Why it happens#
Partly because more works for both kinds of noun: more apples, more applesauce. Its opposite looks like it should too. AHD points out that plural nouns and mass nouns behave alike in many ways, which makes the rule "often hard to follow in practice."
Partly because fewer sounds stiff. The Cambridge Dictionary blog notes that fewer comes across as formal, especially before than, and that many native speakers use less all the time in informal speech. That's descriptive, not permission. In a report or an exam, the count rule still applies.
The fix#
This version has less bugs than the last one.
This version has fewer bugs than the last one.
Bugs are counted one by one, so the word is fewer.
Test it by putting a number in front: three bugs works, so it's fewer bugs. Three sugar doesn't, so it's less sugar.
Where "less" is correct with a plural#
This is where over-correctors trip. AHD lists several well-established uses:
- Time, money and distance: less than three weeks, less than $400, less than 50 miles. You're treating the total as one amount, not a pile of separate dollars.
- "Or less" and "no less than": Give your reasons in 25 words or less; No less than 30 of his colleagues signed the letter.
- "More or less": two dozen apples, more or less.
Oxford adds scores and similar measurements: a score of less than 100. AHD warns that forcing fewer into these spots "sounds fastidious." Fewer than $400 isn't more correct. It just makes you sound like you're counting dollar bills.
About that supermarket sign#
"10 items or less" is the classic exhibit. The Cambridge blog recounts that in 2008 the British chain Tesco replaced the wording after complaints. On the advice of the Plain English Campaign, it went with "Up to 10 items." The blog's author points out the irony: the new sign is correct but less clear, since it no longer says whether ten items are allowed or only nine.
AHD's panel was "a little more accepting (but still not in favor)" of the express-lane version than of other uses of less with plurals. So if you're writing the sign, "10 items or fewer" is the safe choice. If you're standing in line, there's no need to correct the cashier.
Sources
Every factual claim on this page links to one of these. Checked November 7, 2026. See how we source.
- American Heritage Dictionary: usage note at 'less' ahdictionary.com
- Cambridge Dictionary blog: Less or fewer? dictionaryblog.cambridge.org
- Oxford Learner's Dictionaries: less (grammar point) oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com